Ernie Ball vs D'Addario
Posted: Fri Apr 07, 2017 7:24 pm
I'm writing this because it has taken me a very long time and a bit of cash to compare these two sting brands, using a Jazzmaster, Telecaster, and Les Paul and through a Fender and Vox amp. Plus, I might be able to save you a few bucks after reading this. Keep in mind that these statements are not facts, but only a careful analysis according to my completely unbiased opinion. Also, the comparisons were set up with NICKLE WOUND 8s and 9-46s on the Telecaster, 9.5s and 9-42s on the Jazzmaster, and 10s and 11s on the Les Paul. Each string gauge was played with both brands, the same guitar, and amp/pedal combinations.
Here are strictly qualities of a D'Addario string:
- Have more grip, especially on the unwound strings (G, B, e)
- Are slightly acoustically louder
- Have more attack, which is especially noticeable when paired with humbuckers
- Feel more textured
- Seem to sustain slightly longer
- Looses new string sound in about 7 hours, which is liked by only 50 percent of guitarists anyways
- Have a little bit more definition under distortion when using hum buckers, fat fuzz, or distortion pedals
- The winding feels slightly flatter and taller, but still nothing close to flat wound. They feel completely different than Ernie Ball strings
Here are strictly qualities of an Ernie Ball string:
- Feel slick and smooth in a great way, especially on the unwound strings (G, B, e)
- Sound brighter; not in a shrill way, but crisp and clear, especially with single coils
- Are more clean sounding. Maybe a bit more definition
- Less buzz when playing slide guitar
- Don't vibrate as much after the first half hour of playing, which is good because they vibrate too much at first
- Looses new string sound in about 4 hours, which is only liked by 50 percent of guitarists anyways
- STAY IN TUNE better and break in faster (after about 10 seconds of pulling each string, and then playing for five minutes with a retuning, the strings hold their pitch exceptionally better then any other string I've played, where it takes a quite a few retunes for D'Addario strings to settle perfectly.)
- The winding feels rounder, shorter, and more spaced out. They feel completely different than Ernie Ball strings
Here are similarities of both strings:
- The ball ends seem to be made the exact same way with only different color balls
- They cost roughly the same depending on where you get them from and state taxing differences
- While D'Addario doesn't show as much physical wear as Ernie Ball strings, both wear out at about the same amount of playing time. Ernie ball strings are shinier and therefore show wear more apparently
Verdict:
While D'Addario and Ernie Ball strings do not sound alike, they are not so different in tone to justify the purchase of one or another without addressing the feel of the strings themselves. That said, if you perfer cleans and single coil pickups, you might find the definition Ernie Ball has to offer magical; If you perfer high gain distortion and humbucking pickups, then you might find the slightly additional initial attack and the tone cutting through more clear under mass distortion more appealing. BUT - and a big but too - there is no reason why either string company doesn't sound any better for either application because it is your ear that matters, not mine. You may have a sound in you're head that you are looking for that is different to mine and that is completely fine. I just hoped this helped a few people.
Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed the comparison. Feel free to comment your opinions as well.
Here are strictly qualities of a D'Addario string:
- Have more grip, especially on the unwound strings (G, B, e)
- Are slightly acoustically louder
- Have more attack, which is especially noticeable when paired with humbuckers
- Feel more textured
- Seem to sustain slightly longer
- Looses new string sound in about 7 hours, which is liked by only 50 percent of guitarists anyways
- Have a little bit more definition under distortion when using hum buckers, fat fuzz, or distortion pedals
- The winding feels slightly flatter and taller, but still nothing close to flat wound. They feel completely different than Ernie Ball strings
Here are strictly qualities of an Ernie Ball string:
- Feel slick and smooth in a great way, especially on the unwound strings (G, B, e)
- Sound brighter; not in a shrill way, but crisp and clear, especially with single coils
- Are more clean sounding. Maybe a bit more definition
- Less buzz when playing slide guitar
- Don't vibrate as much after the first half hour of playing, which is good because they vibrate too much at first
- Looses new string sound in about 4 hours, which is only liked by 50 percent of guitarists anyways
- STAY IN TUNE better and break in faster (after about 10 seconds of pulling each string, and then playing for five minutes with a retuning, the strings hold their pitch exceptionally better then any other string I've played, where it takes a quite a few retunes for D'Addario strings to settle perfectly.)
- The winding feels rounder, shorter, and more spaced out. They feel completely different than Ernie Ball strings
Here are similarities of both strings:
- The ball ends seem to be made the exact same way with only different color balls
- They cost roughly the same depending on where you get them from and state taxing differences
- While D'Addario doesn't show as much physical wear as Ernie Ball strings, both wear out at about the same amount of playing time. Ernie ball strings are shinier and therefore show wear more apparently
Verdict:
While D'Addario and Ernie Ball strings do not sound alike, they are not so different in tone to justify the purchase of one or another without addressing the feel of the strings themselves. That said, if you perfer cleans and single coil pickups, you might find the definition Ernie Ball has to offer magical; If you perfer high gain distortion and humbucking pickups, then you might find the slightly additional initial attack and the tone cutting through more clear under mass distortion more appealing. BUT - and a big but too - there is no reason why either string company doesn't sound any better for either application because it is your ear that matters, not mine. You may have a sound in you're head that you are looking for that is different to mine and that is completely fine. I just hoped this helped a few people.
Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed the comparison. Feel free to comment your opinions as well.