Page 1 of 1

If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Wed Nov 22, 2023 3:40 am
by mark76

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Wed Nov 22, 2023 3:51 am
by MattK
Looks better than the Squier one.

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Tue Nov 28, 2023 10:36 pm
by PlayWithPride
LOL! No it doesn't. Looks like the shitty copy that it is with no aesthetic sense of proportions and a gimped headstock.

It also has no meaningful warranty and is made by "Harley Benton" -- a guitar company that doesn't actually exist and is just a label Thomann has put on third-rate guitars it has made in factories that can't get contracts with Fender (or other real guitar companies) to make budget copies of their guitars. It costs a fortune to have them shipped to the US and good luck finding parts that actually fit Harley Benton's too.

This is not good news. Not for anyone who cares about quality and isn't just looking for more ugly wall art.

Here's what a real one looks like for comparison:
Image

It also came in all black like the dreadful HB
Image

There's a reason why people would rather pay $1200 for the Squier than a fraction of that to buy a fake HB.

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Wed Nov 29, 2023 1:14 am
by UlricvonCatalyst
PlayWithPride wrote:
Tue Nov 28, 2023 10:36 pm
LOL! No it doesn't. Looks like the shitty copy that it is....would rather pay $1200 for the Squier than a fraction of that to buy a fake HB.
Yes, but if you bought one of those you'd have enough left over for a Class A sarcasm detector. ;)

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2023 3:28 pm
by Snake Hips
Why did those ever come with a strat input jack......

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2023 8:13 pm
by Fiddy
Because uncool is cool these days. So Strat jacks are bringing sexy back.

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2023 9:54 pm
by JVG
It’s very black….

Image

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2023 7:23 am
by Dollywitch
PlayWithPride wrote:
Tue Nov 28, 2023 10:36 pm
LOL! No it doesn't. Looks like the shitty copy that it is with no aesthetic sense of proportions and a gimped headstock.

It also has no meaningful warranty and is made by "Harley Benton" -- a guitar company that doesn't actually exist and is just a label Thomann has put on third-rate guitars it has made in factories that can't get contracts with Fender (or other real guitar companies) to make budget copies of their guitars. It costs a fortune to have them shipped to the US and good luck finding parts that actually fit Harley Benton's too.

This is not good news. Not for anyone who cares about quality and isn't just looking for more ugly wall art.

Here's what a real one looks like for comparison:
Image

It also came in all black like the dreadful HB
Image

There's a reason why people would rather pay $1200 for the Squier than a fraction of that to buy a fake HB.
Someone's never played a HB. They're generally the same quality as Squier for less cost.

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2023 2:56 am
by f__P
Yup, Harley Bentons are generally well made guitars. I have played their Bass VI and the neck is super good. Pups are not that great but it's easy to just switch them. Telecaster have also gained some kind of cult following.
I can see myself buying a 12 string electric in the near future, BTW

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2023 12:17 am
by X-Ray Spex
PlayWithPride wrote:
Tue Nov 28, 2023 10:36 pm
LOL! No it doesn't. Looks like the shitty copy that it is with no aesthetic sense of proportions and a gimped headstock.

It also has no meaningful warranty and is made by "Harley Benton" -- a guitar company that doesn't actually exist and is just a label Thomann has put on third-rate guitars it has made in factories that can't get contracts with Fender (or other real guitar companies) to make budget copies of their guitars. It costs a fortune to have them shipped to the US and good luck finding parts that actually fit Harley Benton's too.

This is not good news. Not for anyone who cares about quality and isn't just looking for more ugly wall art.

Here's what a real one looks like for comparison:
Image

It also came in all black like the dreadful HB
Image

There's a reason why people would rather pay $1200 for the Squier than a fraction of that to buy a fake HB.
Every Harley Benton I've played has been excellent, my friend has one of these and it absolutely rips.

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2023 4:09 am
by mark76
Where were the Squier baritones made?

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2023 6:20 am
by bessieboporbach
I was genuinely not expecting an angry assertion of the superiority of Squier products and the factories that make them (!) in this thread.

Let's leave aside the question of whether Harley Benton guitars are, on average, better or worse than Squiers. Why should anyone who is not an investor in FMIC care about defending the brand reputation of Squier? Or Fender for that matter?

Re: If You Missed Out On The Squier JM Bari...

Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2023 7:40 am
by Fiddy
Probably all subcontracted to the same factories anyhow?